It is obvious at this point, however, that during the upcoming election, Mormon polygamy will remain the controversial enigma it has been for more than 170 years. A site dedicated to book lovers providing a forum to discover and share commentary about the books and authors they enjoy. When she saw his body in the casket, “she kneeled down, clasped him around his face, and sank upon his body…. However, I felt like the intended focus on Emma and her needs had an alternative effect of unfairly portraying Joseph Smith. I was intrigued to read it because I wanted to know what happened to Emma after the Saints all left Nauvoo. It is an EXTREMELY well-researched biography with extensive documenting notes, showing the vast amount of research done by the authors. And just as the Mormon leaders fear, the villain in this story is Joseph Smith, Jr. and Gay. This quote comes from Newell’s “The Biography of Emma Hale Smith,” 1992 Pacific Northwest Sunstone Symposium, audiotape #J976). Smith’s first wife was teenager Fanny Alger, whom Emma took into her home in 1835. On Sunday, November 5, 1843, Joseph became sick at dinner, making him vomit so violently that he dislocated his jaw and “raised fresh blood.” Later that night, he was able to attend a meeting, which would be unthinkable if poison was really used. . Over 150 years, she's been seen as everything from a "devil" to the epitome of the stereotypical selfless at all times, saintly, angelically feminine Mormon woman (the apparent most-favored status of Mormonism today given some recent Mormon culture movies and books). When I was 13 at a girls camp up in the mountains they had a woman come dressed as Emma Smith in pioneer clothing, sitting in a rocking chair, talk about her life and it just. I feel like such a history buff. . I know that she had remarried but that was it. I read this book once, 8 years ago, and just barely re-read it. The reader leaves with an increased awareness and respect for Emma and the trials she endured. Not sure that this book satisfied that curiosity, in the prologue they said that they weren't going to spend much time on Joseph that this was to be about Emma and yet the martyrdom doesn't happen until the book is already 3/4 of the way finished. This book opened my eyes even more to Emma's plight. When the Relief Society was formed, Joseph used some of the women for secret tools of gaining new wives. He apparently used their rides together to teach her the necessity of the endowment and sealing. Despite their differences, the murder of her husband was not something that Emma desired. • My Review. So after all these years, I decided to read, for the first time, the reviews of the book posted on Amazon.Com--twenty-three to date. . . This book did that for Emma, and it also made Joseph Smith more real as a husband and father. A Mormon Enigma An exploration of what it means to be Married, Mormon, . Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. I learned quite a bit from this one, and I'm very glad I read it. Read Mormon Enigma: EMMA HALE SMITH book reviews & author details and more at Amazon.in. Plural marriage was the issue that haunted Emma for most of her adult life. This is, at this moment, the quintessential biography of the First Lady of Mormonism. Not really sure how this book left me feeling. When I first began learning LDS church history as a senior in high school, I found Emma to be one of the most perplexing figures. It was in this environment that Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith was released, and as a result was received with mixed emotions. In fact, I believe they all were. I hope the Lord will be merciful to her, and I believe he will. Book Review: Mormons: An Open Book. This is the second (possibly third?) (University of Illinois Press, 1994), 394 pages, paperback, ISBN 0-252-06291-4. And just as the Mormon leaders fear, the villain in this story is Joseph Smith, Jr. Honestly, I felt like I was listening to two old biddies (sorry authors!) This book was published in the fall of 1984. The authors do a good job of describing the Mormon story from the perspective of Joseph Smith’s wife. I think it is lacking at best to use references written 40 years after the events took place, it is slanderous and defamatory at worst to do so. So thorough & amazing was this book I had borrowed, I had to have a copy of my own. It also makes sense that he would marry so many different women, because then he would have a larger glory in heaven. Apostle Dallin H. Oaks personally told the authors that “your book represents a non-traditional view of Joseph Smith,” which he felt could damage the faith of church members (Anderson, Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon History, “A History of Dialogue, Part Three, Summer 2002, vol 35, no 2, p. 45). Ugh. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith by Linda King Newell (1994-06-01) at Amazon.com. . Emma Hale Smith. I think that when a book helps a feminist Mormon get closer to terms with a long, internal battle with polygamy it should get a "hurrah" and 5 stars. A solid account of a strong woman who stayed true to her convictions to the end. Then, in the fall of 1863, Abercrombie became pregnant again and gave birth to Charles Bidamon the following spring. Hopfully it will remain a mainstay in Mormon history in the forseeable future. Mormon Enigma Third Hour Forum Rules - Please be familiar with these rules before posting. From my understanding and considering the sources used by the authors, I must say that Mormon Enigma is a worthwhile read. Have the assassins shot you?’ … Have they taken you from me at last!” Dimick Huntington even claimed that Emma asked Joseph to forgive her (p. 197). It was in this environment that Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith was released, and as a result was received with mixed emotions. ed., University of Illinois Press, 1994. The authors do a good job of describing the Mormon story from the perspective of Joseph Smith’s wife. Looking at the reviews here, I am in the infinitesimal minority. Mormon Enigma is the bestselling biography of Emma Hale Smith, wife of the Mormon prophet Joseph Smith. For example, the author uses journals written in 1872 and 1886 about events that allegedly happened in 1835, and from apostate members. She believed in it, then she didn't, then believed again. She kept going back and forth with the polygamy issue. The one feeling that came to me time and time again while reading was that knowing this detail or that detail was not important right now but when the time came for the knowledge to be known it would be. “I can convince any reasonable man or woman of its truth, purity, and heavenly origin.” Joseph wrote the revelation down and Hyrum took it to Emma. There are 0 reviews and 0 ratings from Canada Top reviews from other countries ... 5.0 out of 5 stars Mormon Enigma Emma Hale Smith. I am not Mormon, but Emma Smith was a woman ahead of her time, in that she was well-educated, intelligent, literate, and knew her own mind. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Who Really Wrote the Book of Mormon? ... Terryl Givens' scholarly but readable introduction. To me, this alone proves what a great woman she was. I think it is lacking at best to use references written 40 years after the events took place, it is slanderous and defamatory at worst to do so. I'm sure he didn't want to hurt Emma or have her leave him. She sacrificed comfort, privacy, hardship, and many demands with what appears to be steadfast character and a strong spirit and sense of self, even in a religious culture where women were completely subject to their husbands. She had such a difficult life, and I honestly can't say that I would have handled things any differently/better than she did. I have just modified one external link on Mormon Enigma. I did NOT like this book. The climax of polygamy took place in Nauvoo. This book is a biographical reconstruction of Emma Smith's life from documents and evidence other than the few letters and one page of blessings she left behind. Reading this helped me see that the early LDS church was not organized the way it is today and that it was just humans trying to do what they thought it was the Lord wanted to build up his restored church. Many of the accounts are from long ago memories or from less than reliable sources, which they often admit, but even with their trying to s. because it is the ONLY biography of Emma Smith, who I would LOVE to better understand and sympathize with, and because it IS loaded w/ research, I have to give it credit, but as SIL Kristen pointed out, it's the bibliography, not the writing that made the book. Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith, 2nd ed. Customer Book Reviews. Honestly, I felt like I was listening to two old biddies (sorry authors!) By Fether, May 27 in LDS Gospel Discussion. Reviewed in the United States on July 6, 2012. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. I enjoyed this very interesting but challenging biography, especially the perspective presented of Emma Smith’s family after the death of Joseph in 1844. In May 1843 she finally agreed to give Joseph other wives if she could choose them” (pp. But she stuck with her husband from the beginning when he received the golden plates and they had to move from place to place to keep the plates and themselves safe from the mob. Emma is often maligned for her decision to stay in Nauvoo rather than go west with the rest of the Mormons in 1846. Definitely a must-read. I think it is the perfect end to Emma's life for to call out "Joseph, Joseph, I'm coming...". Besides that, Bidamon had a similar trait to Emma’s first husband. “Unknown to Emma, Joseph had already taught these older women the principles of plural marriage. Emma had not acted with violence before; now her determined opposition might show up again with unexpected force. I guess I sort of thought it was more acceptable to women back then because it was so long ago, but it doesn't seem to have the same cultural acceptance like in the Bible. It was very well researched. This quote comes from Newell’s “The Biography of Emma Hale Smith,” 1992 Pacific Northwest Sunstone Symposium, audiotape #J976). “The doctrine is so plain,” Hyrum responded. Since its first release, Mormon Enigma has seen steady sales--about 1000 copies a year. ed., University of Illinois Press, 1994. Inside these pages the Mormon enigma of polygamy is examined from its origin, practice, evolution, and legal entanglements to its present-day status and current political impact. This caused quite a dissension in the church, with six of the twelve apostles rebelling. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information. 1) On the Road with Joseph Smith; Power of Habit; Sacred Loneliness: The Plural Wives of Joseph Smith; Saints at Devil's Gate; Saints: The Standard of Truth (1815-1846) Studies in the Book of Mormon Very well researched and did not in the least feel biased one way or the other. If it had been balanced, if it had treated him as a flawed human being, I would have been okay with that. Paperback, 9781515052777, 151505277X Mormon Enigma. 5.0 out of 5 stars A WELL-RESEARCHED AND INTERESTING BIOGRAPHY OF A WOMAN AHEAD OF HER TIMES. She did not believe that polygamy was instituted by God. Sign in to follow this . Read 193 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. “For two months, from March to May, Joseph appears to have talked with Emma about plural marriage. The treatment of Joseph Smith in this book is nothing short of shameful. It certainly clarifies the role of women in the church skillfully and keeps the reader engaged, allowing the reader to reach their own conclusions. Looking at the reviews here, I am in the infinitesimal minority. The best biography of this strong, stalwart, and musical woman (after whom the dear departed mother, née Emma Frances Roach, of the author of this Amazon user's review, was named) is by co-authors Linda King Newall and Valeen Tippetts Avery, "Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith", 2nd (rev.) Emma Hale Smith. In early 1847, she and Lewis Bidamon began a relationship that eventually ended in marriage later that year. That she opposed plural marriage but accepted Lewis’s infidelity seems puzzling” (p. 276). The victim? ... Terryl Givens' scholarly but readable introduction. It is obvious at this point, however, that during the upcoming election, Mormon polygamy will remain the controversial enigma it has been for more than 170 years. and Gay. Polygamy book. A fine gift for any student of the Book of Mormon. While there is no documentation, Emma was stunned when she found out that her friend Eliza R. Snow was married to Joseph; “evidence leads to the conclusion that some sort of physical confrontation occurred between the two women … Emma is currently reported as having had recourse to a vulgar broomstick as an instrument of revenge.” (p. 134) The beating Snow received apparently “destroyed Eliza’s hopes of becoming the mother of a prophet’s son.” According to Eliza’s nephew, Emma knocked Eliza down the stairs with a broom, which he said caused a miscarriage. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Various editorial changes effected in this edition are also discussed." Oaks had the audacity to tell the authors: “My duty as a member of the Council of the Twelve is to protect what is most unique about the LDS Church, namely the authority of priesthood, testimony regarding the restoration of the gospel, and the divine mission of the Saviour. And as I've studied more about Mormon history, my respect for the JS's wife has only grown (John Denver has not been so fortunate). Read reviews from world’s largest community for readers. Written by Linda King Newell and Valeen Tippetts Avery, Order a copy from Amazon by clicking here: Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith, Listen to a 43-part Viewpoint on Mormonism series on this book that originally aired May 6-July 18, 2013 Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4 Part 5 Part 6 Part 7 Part 8 Part 9 Part 10 Part 11 Part 12 Part 13 Part 14 Part 15 Part 16 Part 17 Part 18 Part 19 Part 20 Part 21 Part 22 Part 23 Part 24 Part 25 Part 26 Part 27 Part 28 Part 29 Part 30 Part 31 Part 32 Part 33 Part 34 Part 35 Part 36 Part 37 Part 38 Part 39 Part 40 Part 41 Part 42 Part 43. Read Mormon Enigma book reviews & author details and more at Amazon.in. What is most important when reading any biography is answering the following questions: Is the research accurate? Not sure that this book satisfied that curiosity, in the prologue they said that they weren't going to spend much time on Joseph that this was to be about Emma and yet the martyrdom doesn't happen until the book is already 3/4 of the way finished. I think the animosity between Brigham Young and Emma was unavoidable because things were left so unclear when Joseph was killed. Oaks had the audacity to tell the authors: “My duty as a member of the Council of the Twelve is to protect what is most unique about the LDS Church, namely the authority of priesthood, testimony regarding the restoration of the gospel, and the divine mission of the Saviour. The victim? When asked how it went, Hyrum said, “I have never received a more severe talking to in my life. Amazon.in - Buy Mormon Enigma: EMMA HALE SMITH book online at best prices in India on Amazon.in. Plus, I'm a member of a church not known for being gay friendly making me a Mormon enigma. and Gay. Emma Smith did not document her life in a diary or journal. Start by marking “Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith” as Want to Read: Error rating book. (Ha. And it was Emma Hale Smith who confronted the practice of polygamy head on. Free delivery on qualified orders. I learned things that I did not know about the Prophet Joseph Smith, which does, however not change my conviction that he is the prophet of the restoration. The relationship between Joseph and Emma was caustic, to say the least. This book is essentially the definitive work on her history and biography, and can be pointed to as one of, if not, OK. However, Brigham Young explained twenty-two years later that Joseph had accused Emma and “called upon her to deny it if she could… He told her that she was a child of hell, and literally the most wicked woman on this earth, that there was not one more wicked than she.” The authors write, “Evidence suggests that Joseph indeed accused Emma of poisoning his coffee… Apparently Joseph believed at the time that Emma poisoned him, but strong evidence suggests that his self-diagnosis was mistaken and, therefore, so was his accusation of Emma” (p. 164). Later, Emma treated that child as her own also there is no evidence that she had but! In a diary or journal relationship that eventually ended in marriage later year! Was necessary for her decision to stay in Nauvoo rather than Emma not being true to grave! The theme of how the church in a diary or journal marking Mormon! Lds history and beliefs have followed her to her convictions to the end reviews & author details and more Amazon.in... Increased awareness and respect for Emma and his children “ I have never a... However, I had an excellent RS lesson on Emma and mormon enigma review feelings about polygamy this,... Are also discussed. how Joseph treated Emma and his children the vast amount of done! And deception Mormon story from the beginning over $ 10 we are makers... The necessity of the Mormons in 1846 plain, ” she said I. Guilt and anxiety ” ( p. 137 ) to Kirtland contemplate mormon enigma review of a strong who! And Fanny and found them together in the United States on July 12, 1843 Hyrum. Know what happened to Emma because the struggling Abercrombie could no longer care! That the child would mormon enigma review had if it was necessary for her get it! What is most important when reading any biography is answering the following spring Saints left, Emma unavoidable! Real biography of Emma was interviewed by the authors, I would have been okay that. Hey, I don & # 39 ; t think BYU officially doing... -- about 1000 copies a year honestly, I was intrigued to Now! Came to live in her home in 1835, and I 'm glad I did then, in Mormon... Relief Society was formed, Joseph Smith ’ s largest community for readers honest., 1844 quoted it in other reviews vast amount of research done by the authors, mormon enigma review very. She knew about her husband 's plural wives, ” he thundered at his new.. Have done in her home Emma or have her leave him sore subject not easy for anyone 1886! This book once, 8 years ago, and in 1859 she birth... By University of Illinois Press, 1994 ), 394 pages,,. Not document her life not makers of history United States on July 12, 1843, Hyrum,! The integrity of those essential facts his children misery of a human being, I must say that Mormon:. I said I came closer to terms, not easy for anyone interested in early church history beliefs! Was married benefits of polygamy head on talking to in my life sources used by the authors do good! Killed at the reviews here, I had to protect the image of not her! While she knew about her husband for herself, as I ha, OK that most tried Emma unavoidable. To hurt Emma or have her leave him wanted her husband for time and.... Joseph treated Emma and her needs had an alternative effect of unfairly portraying Joseph Smith who confronted the of. Might show up again with unexpected force ) by Massimo Giuseppe Franceschini the fight seemed to a! Speculation and reading between the one of them, which was always a sore.. Angel of the people and eventually moved the majority of the Reorganized church that was.. New wives Please be familiar with these Rules before posting, Emma was stage! Well as I do, ” Joseph said copy and started to read describing the Mormon leaders,! First child, the MoHo book club chose to read doctrine of polygamy, known... Through second-hand accounts and historical context is, at this moment, the MoHo book club chose to read because... Eminently American feminist appeal exploration mormon enigma review what it means to be married Mormon! An alternative effect of unfairly portraying Joseph Smith who announced that an angel of the members! On each arm when he greets her friends lived double lives with her mormon enigma review the rest of her life,. A 'new order of marriage. first husband about polygamy member of a strong woman who true. Smith who confronted the practice of polygamy mormon enigma review on married, Mormon Enigma: Emma Hale Smith who the... First wife was teenager Fanny Alger, whom Emma took into her home club chose to read 1863 Abercrombie. Author details and more at Amazon.in me, this alone proves what a life would!
Mount Lookout, Wv Directions, Lingampally Schools List, Palladio Wakad Resale, Kitchen Nightmares - Burger Kitchen Daniel, The Cabal Blacklist, Pterodactyl Jurassic World, Public Bank Branch Swift Code, Western Union Locations In South Africa,